Star Trek Episode 2: Charlie X

General Information

Director: Lawrence Dobkin

Writer: D.C. Fontana

Cast: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, Robert Walker, DeForest Kelley, Grace Lee Whitney, Nichelle Nichols, Charles J. Stewart, Dallas Mitchell, Don Eitner, Patricia McNulty, John Bellah, Garland Thompson, and Abraham Sofaer

Composer: Fred Steiner

Air Date: 9/15/1966

Stardate: 1533.6

Production #: 6149-08

 

Overview

During a rendezvous with the cargo vessel Antares, Charlie Evans (Robert Walker)—a seventeen-year-old human who spent most of his life alone on the planet Thasus—beams aboard the Enterprise. Before long, Charlie develops star-trek-charlie-xinappropriate feelings for Captain Kirk’s yeoman, Janice Rand. Despite his efforts to influence Charlie in a positive direction, Kirk remains unable to prevent his young guest—now revealed to possess alien powers—from harming or killing those who irritate him.

A monster-of-the-week episode, “Charlie X” lacks an insightful message to complement its generic, horror-themed subject matter. That being said, the interactions between Charlie and Kirk—who conducts himself like a father figure while in Charlie’s presence—provide a fascinating character study amidst a formulaic narrative.

 

Pros

Robert Walker deserves praise for his portrayal of Charlie, whose telekinesis is made especially frightening due to the mental immaturity, absence of restraint, andstar-trek-charlie-x childlike petulance that he exhibits during his stay on the Enterprise.

It should also be noted that as opposed to Anthony from The Twilight Zone, Charlie commits terrible crimes out of frustration (implied to stem from his limited understanding of human relationships) rather than pure malevolence—an aspect that allows Charlie to remain sympathetic, if not overly likable, from the perspective of the audience.

 

Cons

By progressing at a languid pace, “Charlie X” fails to generate a satisfactory level of tension.

 

Analysis

(Spoilers beyond this point)

star-trek-charlie-xThe trials of Charlie Evans seem almost symbolic of the adapting process that children must undergo upon entering adolescence. Specifically, Charlie never attempts to bridle his phenomenal talents with the self-control of a responsible adult, eventually prompting the Thasian people to remove him from the company of his human peers—a veiled commentary on the fact that teenagers must learn to govern their impulses, sexual or otherwise, in order function within society.

 

Concluding Comments

“Charlie X” puts a scientific twist on the trope later popularized by Carrie, a Stephen King novel about a high school student who experiences telekinetic rage on her prom night. Fans of the sci-fi/horror crossover genre may therefore wish to view this offering, which benefits from a compelling, albeit slow, execution.

 

Overall Quality: 7/10

 

If you enjoyed this post, please enter your email address in the subscription box to stay tuned for more updates.

Please note: Comments that are malicious, offensive, or excessively profane will be removed. Off-topic messages belong in the About section.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *