Star Trek Episode 12: The Menagerie Part II

General Information

Director: Robert Butler

Writer: Gene Roddenberry

Cast: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, Jeffrey Hunter, Susan Oliver, Malachi Throne, Majel Barrett, Peter Duryea, John Hoyt, Laurel Goodwin, Adam Roarke, DeForest Kelley, James Doohan, Nichelle Nichols, Sean Kenney, Hagan Beggs, and Meg Wyllie

Composer: Alexander Courage

Air Date: 11/24/1966

Stardate: 3013.1

Production #: 6149-16B

 

Overview

At Spock’s court martial, the board reviews 13-year-old footage of Captain Pike’s imprisonment on Talos IV. Despite failing to see the relevance of the video star-trek-the-menagerie-part-IItestimony, Captain Kirk and Commodore Mendez soon discover the true reason for Spock’s mutiny.

“The Menagerie Part II” offers a poignant conclusion to the plight of Captain Pike—rendered mute, paralyzed, and disfigured by delta ray exposure. Star Trek fans should therefore enjoy this entry, which suffers only from minor continuity flaws.

 

Pros

Similar to the “The Menagerie Part I,” this episode builds a clever framing narrative around the events of “The Cage”—the first pilot created for Star Trek: The Original Series star-trek-the-menagerie-part-II(the second being “Where No Man Has Gone Before” from earlier in season one). Specifically, the Enterprise crew members watch in awe as the Talosians, advanced aliens who use the power of illusion to dominate others, relay historical images of Pike’s journey to Talos IV and subsequent capture, confinement, and release—a slick manner of introducing Pike, Vina, and the Talosians into the official canon of this series.

 

Cons

(Spoilers beyond this point)

star-trek-the-menagerie-part-IIIn an apparent gesture of sympathy, the Talosians agree to care for Pike and restore his former self via illusion. During “The Cage,” however, the Talosians demonstrate no regard for human beings beyond their utilitarian value, even going so far as to torture Pike and Vina in response to insubordination.

 

Analysis

Willing to sacrifice his life and career for a friend in need, Spock reveals a sentimental side to his personality in this episode—an aspect that will likely resonate with viewers of a sensitive nature.

 

Concluding Comments

Combining the cerebral science fiction of “The Cage” with a captivating mystery, “The Menagerie Part II” deserves its reputation as a classic episode of Star Trek. Especially worth praising is the ultimate fate of Pike, who, due to the selfless actions of Spock, receives a second chance at living a normal life.

 

Overall Quality: 10/10

 

If you enjoyed this post, please enter your email address in the subscription box to stay tuned for more updates.

Please note: Comments that are malicious, offensive, or excessively profane will be removed. Off-topic messages belong in the About section.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *